The Power of Over-Generation in Vibe Coding

You know that feeling when you ask an AI to write some code and it gives you three different versions instead of one

My first reaction was honestly annoyance like why can’t it just give me the right answer the first time

But then I started seeing something interesting happening

When I had multiple options to choose from I found myself actually thinking more deeply about what I really wanted

It reminded me of that principle about treating code as capability while intentions and interfaces become our long-term assets

Think about it when you’re presented with several working solutions you stop focusing on the code itself and start focusing on which approach best matches your actual needs

You begin to see patterns in what works and what doesn’t

You develop a better sense of what makes a good prompt versus a mediocre one

I remember working on this data processing script where I kept getting variations that all technically worked but each had different tradeoffs

One was super fast but used more memory

Another was memory efficient but slower

A third was beautifully readable but less optimized

Having these options forced me to clarify what mattered most for this specific use case

Was this script going to run in a memory-constrained environment

Would other developers need to understand and modify it later

These are the kinds of questions that get you thinking at the intention level rather than just the implementation level

Over-generation essentially turns coding into a conversation

Instead of a single answer you get a discussion about different approaches

You learn what your AI assistant considers important enough to vary

You start to understand its design sensibilities

And most importantly you become more intentional about your own choices

This aligns perfectly with the shift toward viewing code as disposable while our prompts and specifications become the valuable artifacts we maintain

The real magic happens when you start using over-generation deliberately

Ask for multiple approaches to the same problem

Request implementations with different priorities

Get variations that emphasize different qualities

Then compare them side by side

What makes one version better than another

Which one feels right for your current context

This process trains your intuition for what makes good software in different situations

It’s like having multiple experienced developers giving you their take on the same problem

Each with their own biases and strengths

Your job becomes curating rather than creating from scratch

You’re the editor not the writer

The director not the actor

This is where vibe coding truly shines

When you stop worrying about writing perfect code and start focusing on making perfect choices

When the quality of your decisions matters more than the quantity of your keystrokes

So next time your AI gives you more than you asked for don’t get frustrated

See it as an opportunity to refine your intentions

To clarify what really matters

And to build that muscle for making better software decisions

Because in the end that’s what separates good developers from great ones

Not how much code they write but how well they choose which code to use